Guys, here is my review of Vinnai thandi varuvaya.
Movie: Vinnai thandi varuvaya
Cast: Silambarasan, Trisha, Ganesh
Director: Gautham Vasudev Menon
Music director: A.R. Rahman
Storyline: A guy falls in love with a girl at first sight. The girl denies her love in the beginning…gradually accepts it but leaves him in the end.
Bottom-line: Old wine in new bottle (Courtesy: Sujatha:-D)
The cliché love story again! Love at first sight…opening song illustrating guy’s love for the girl; Guy proposes, girl denies, and then agrees to be friends! Girl finally falls in love with him, but leaves him in the end when she realizes they cannot end up together. To sum up, VTV is just another love story that we people have seen and read and heard of. So, what’s new about this love story, one may ask. Well, as mentioned above, it’s just old wine in new bottle. But wine, they say (having never tasted it myself ;)) tastes sweeter and better as it ages. But unfortunately, that is not quite true in this case.
Let’s start with the pros of the film. One of the biggest, or if I may say, the biggest asset of this movie is, without a doubt, its music! Kudos to the Academy award winning composer Rahman for his heart-melting tracks. All I can say is, he has done it again. Be it the peppy Hosanna or the musical delight Omana pennae, one cannot help but get addicted to his music. Rahman’s wonderful music accompanied by Thamarai’s beautiful lyrics is just wow!!! The thirukkural addition in “Mannipaaya” is something very new. Lines like “Ananivarum urangidum iravenum neram, enakkadhu thalaiyanai nanaithium neram” in Mannipaaya, “Kadhal kondu naan pesa…kathi thooki nee veesa…pakkam vandhu thottu pesum kanavugal kandaen….innum satru aruge vandhu muthamum thandhaen…ithanai nadandhum kadhal illai yenbadhu sariya…aanaai naanum pennaai neeyum irupadhu pizhaiya”, in “Kannukkul” bring a small smile to your lips! If you have only listened to the movie’s album, you have only experienced half of the magic. You have got to go to the theatre to see the awesome cinematography of the songs. They are simply wonderful. Hosanna, shot in Malta, Omana pennae, showing the vast expanse of the blue sea are visual treats! A round of applause to the art director Rajeevan, for portraying Rahman’s music so beautifully. Small touches like when Karthik (Simbu) squeezes Jesse’s (Trisha) feet, Karthik’s joy when he first sees Jesse and many more light up your face and warm your heart. Also, this is without a doubt, the best movie of Simbu and Trisha, yet! What a make-over for both of them! They have never looked better. I was actually cheering for Simbu’s entry!!! The director sure knows how to groom his stars…! Nalini’s costumes are to be appreciated. The actors have done a pretty good job. Trisha, especially, has given her best to this role.
Coming to the cons, well, they are many! First of all, the dialogues were a major let-down. After Vaaranam aayiram, I am sure all our expectations were sky-high. Mine were of course, the same and boy was I disappointed! Some of the dialogues were so…cheap! I mean, I, for one, definitely did not expect the classy Gautham menon to write such dialogues. The movie’s pace was also extremely slow. Jesse’s characterization was poor and showed her as an extremely confused person. She rejected Karthik 4 times!!! (I am not kidding!) First she refuses, then accepts, then refuses, then accepts, then refuses…gets engaged to another guy, leaves the poor guy at the altar, then accepts Karthik again and finally refuses! Phew! Karthik sure has a lot of patience!!! :P Also, the editor should have been careful with the twist in the end. When “Anbil avan” started, people actually thought the movie had ended and started leaving the hall, thereby missing the most important part of the film. The editor should have given a hint of some sort that the movie was not over yet.
The film was definitely disappointing if you had any expectations. However, if you didn’t expect anything great and definitely not something like Vaaranam aayiram’s magic again, you will probably like it!
PS: Copyrights reserved to me, and me only!!! :P
hey!!! Superb review di!!! I thought the director lost track of his story after a point... Our in-house movie critic - KUDOS to you!!!!
ReplyDeleteBy the by, waiting for your review of KITES.... do pen it soon...
ReplyDeletethank u!! yeah sure... i ll do that!
ReplyDeleteMy answer to Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya is " Vara maatten"! What personal problem does Gautam Menon have against me and my fellow human beings? Why does he build up a beautiful story like riding on a massive wave only to crash us on some jagged rocks! The movie started off refreshingly nicely, but what the heck was that on-again-off-again game Trisha was playing? Agreed there were no villians ( other than the girl's bro and his gang), agreed there was no mandatory comedic interruptions by Vadivelu or one of his tribe. You like some movies and you end up not liking some. This falls under the third category which gives you a strong headache and leaves you going " Why, oh God, why?"
ReplyDeleteWhat happenned after Simbu goes to Goa is so vague. This is a long comment, may have to make it 2 parts. Trisha could have either eloped with him or stayed stubborn with her dad and remained single thereby upholding her love. The confusion in the climax was too much! I actually felt sorry for Simbu's character. He, for one, was as clean and polished as a new silver plate compared to his usual sleaze. It's a case of excellent protagonists and very bad story telling. Menon should make a movie up to 60% and hand it over to some protege of his, some 21/22 yr old aspiring director like Simbu's Karthik to complete the film. The climax , exactly like that of Pacchaikili muthucaharam was a total, utter let down, it was so bad I thought it was capable of instigating violence in the theatre, where people start bashing up their neighbors.
Honestly, in contrast, I like Cheran's Pokkisham a lot more. Slow, boring were the words used to describe that movie that sank without a trace. The story itself was a lot more powerful and if you give yourself a chance to believe in love stories, that one was way more rapturous than VTV. fantastic music, great locales, eye cpativating cinematography. But just a case of emperor's new clothes! Menon, someone is going to throw a rock at your house if you keep making movies with brilliant beginnings & trashy endings!
Very good comprehensive review, Viju. Sorry wanted to read your article only after self-flagellating myself with this movie!